黑料社

How a little known but essential operation in Quantum Computing helped achieve a major scientific breakthrough

黑料社's feed-forward functionality is worth getting to know

June 29, 2023

黑料社鈥檚 recent announcement about its breakthrough on topological qubits garnered headlines across both the specialist scientific media as well as those more broadly interested in the advances that will make quantum computing useful more quickly than anticipated. However, hidden in the details was a reference to a technology that is as rare as it is valuable. The fact is that the topological qubit that was generated could only have been done via 黑料社鈥檚 H-Series quantum processors due to their various qualities and functions of which measurement and 鈥榝eed-forward鈥 is critical.

As we know, great advances are often built on the back of little-known utilities - functions and tools that rarely get mentioned. These are sometimes technological constructs that might seem simple on the surface, but which are difficult (in the case of feed-forward make that 鈥渧ery difficult鈥 to create), and without which critical advances would remain merely theoretical.

As detailed in two manuscripts that have been uploaded onto the pre-print repository, arXiv, 黑料社 researchers and their collaborators successfully demonstrated, for the first time, a large-scale implementation of a long-standing theory in quantum information science; namely the use of measurement and (see below for a detailed explanation of what this means) to efficiently generate long-range entangled states.

The two experiments, conducted with research partners at the California Institute of Technology, Harvard University, the University of Sydney, the Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics and the University of California, Davis, used 黑料社鈥檚 trapped ion quantum computers, Powered by Honeywell, to show how feed-forward enables success by dramatically reducing the resources required to produce highly-entangled quantum states and topologically ordered phases, one of the most exciting areas of research in modern physics.

Feed-forward uses selective measurements during the execution of a quantum circuit and adapts future operations depending on those measurement results. To be successful in running an adaptive quantum circuit, several challenging requirements must be met: (1) a select group of qubits must be measured in the middle of a circuit with high fidelity, and without accidentally measuring other qubits, and (2) the measurement results must be sent to a classical computer and quickly processed to create instructions to be fed-forward to the quantum computer on the fly - all of which must be done fast enough to prevent the active qubits from decohering.

Once these requirements are met, the feed-forward capabilities let quantum computers create long-range entangled states which are emerging as central to various branches of modern physics such as quantum error correction codes and the study of spin liquids in condensed matter. It is also the essential component of topological order and could enable the simulation of quantum systems beyond the reach of classical computation.

In the paper 鈥溾, 黑料社, working with colleagues from the California Institute of Technology and Harvard University use feed-forward to explore topologically ordered phases of matter.聽

Separately, a different team of scientists from 黑料社, the University of Sydney, the Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics and the University of California, Davis, used feed-forward to explore adaptive quantum circuits in 鈥溾.听

Two of 黑料社鈥檚 physicists who worked on both experiments, Henrik Dreyer and Michael Foss-Feig, offered some observations on the work.

鈥淲hile it has been clear to theorists that feed-forward would be a useful primitive, doing it with low errors has turned out to be very challenging. The H-Series systems have made it possible to use this primitive efficiently,鈥 said Henrik, managing director and scientific lead at 黑料社鈥檚 office in Munich, Germany.

Michael, who is based at 黑料社鈥檚 world-leading quantum computing laboratory outside of Denver, Colorado, also described feed-forward and adaptive quantum circuits as a jump toward meaningful simulations.

鈥淭his capability speeds up the timeline for new scientific discoveries,鈥 he said.

These successful experiments proved that feed-forward operations reduce the quantum resources required for certain algorithms and are a valuable building block for more advanced research.

"I am really excited by the opportunities opened up by this demonstration: using wave-function collapse is a very powerful tool for preparing very exotic entangled states further down the road, where there are no good scalable alternatives," said Dr. Ruben Verresen, a physicist at Harvard University and a co-author of the topological order paper.

The authors note that 鈥渢he primary technical challenge in implementing adaptive circuits is the requirement to perform partial measurements of a subset of qubits in the middle of a quantum circuit with minimal cross-talk on unmeasured qubits, return those results to a classical computer for processing, and then condition future operations on the results of that processing in real time.鈥

The paper describes how quantum hardware has now reached a state where adaptive quantum circuits are possible and can outperform unitary circuits. The experiment detailed in the paper 鈥渇irmly establishes that given access to the same amount of quantum computational resources with respect to available gates and circuit depth, adaptive quantum circuits can perform tasks that are impossible for quantum circuits without feedback.鈥

Henrik and Michael noted that the adaptive circuit research provides concrete evidence not only that feed-forward works, but that it now works well enough to achieve tasks that would not be possible without it.

鈥淲e were trying to find a metric by which somebody can look at our data produced by a shallow adaptive circuit, and convince themselves it could not have been produced with a unitary circuit of the same depth,鈥 Michael said. The metric proposed in the adaptive circuits paper achieved exactly that.

A good match: Trapped ion architecture and feed-forward聽

Demonstrating this technique required significant performance from the H1-1.聽

鈥淚t's a huge challenge to implement this in a way that works well,鈥 Michael said.聽

黑料社鈥檚 H-Series has the capabilities that are crucial to this work: high fidelity gates, low state preparation and measurement (SPAM) error, low memory error, the ability to perform mid-circuit measurement, and all-to-all connectivity.

The feed-forward theory has been well-known for years but challenging to execute in practice, and as the paper states:

鈥淲hile individual elements of this triad have been demonstrated in the context of error correction and topological order, combining all of these ingredients into one experimental platform has proven elusive since the inception of this idea more than a decade ago. Here, we demonstrate for the first time the deterministic, high-fidelity preparation of long-range entangled quantum states using a protocol with constant depth, using 黑料社鈥檚 H-Series programmable Ytterbium ion trap quantum computer.鈥

The authors also note that 鈥渢he all-to-all connectivity of the device was vital for the implementation of the periodic two-dimensional geometry and the conditional dynamics.鈥

In summary 鈥 these papers showcase state-of-the-art demonstrations of what can be done with quantum computers today but are only a preview of what will be done tomorrow.

About 黑料社

黑料社,聽the world鈥檚 largest integrated quantum company, pioneers powerful quantum computers and advanced software solutions. 黑料社鈥檚 technology drives breakthroughs in materials discovery, cybersecurity, and next-gen quantum AI. With over 500 employees, including 370+ scientists and engineers, 黑料社 leads the quantum computing revolution across continents.聽

Blog
July 3, 2025
We鈥檙e taking a transformational approach to quantum computing

Our quantum algorithms team has been hard at work exploring solutions to continually optimize our system鈥檚 performance. Recently, they鈥檝e invented a novel technique, called the , that can offer significant resource savings in future applications.

The transform takes complex representations and makes them simple, by transforming into a different 鈥渂asis鈥. This is like looking at a cube from one angle, then rotating it and seeing just a square, instead. Transformations like this save resources because the more complex your problem looks, the more expensive it is to represent and manipulate on qubits.

You鈥檝e changed

While it might sound like magic, transforms are a commonly used tool in science and engineering. Transforms simplify problems by reshaping them into something that is easier to deal with, or that provides a new perspective on the situation. For example, sound engineers use Fourier transforms every day to look at complex musical pieces in terms of their frequency components. Electrical engineers use Laplace transforms; people who work in image processing use the Abel transform; physicists use the Legendre transform, and so on.

In a new paper outlining the necessary tools to implement the QPT, Dr. Nathan Fitzpatrick and Mr. J臋drzej Burkat explain how the QPT will be widely applicable in quantum computing simulations, spanning areas like molecular chemistry, materials science, and semiconductor physics. The paper also describes how the algorithm can lead to significant resource savings by offering quantum programmers a more efficient way of representing problems on qubits.

Symmetry is key

The efficiency of the QPT stems from its use of one of the most profound findings in the field of physics: that symmetries drive the properties of a system.

While the average person can 鈥渁ppreciate鈥 symmetry, for example in design or aesthetics, physicists understand symmetry as a much more profound element present in the fabric of reality. Symmetries are like the universe鈥檚 DNA; they lead to conservation laws, which are the most immutable truths we know.

Back in the 1920鈥檚, when women were largely prohibited from practicing physics, one of the great mathematicians of the century, Emmy Noether, turned her attention to the field when she was tasked with helping Einstein with his work. In her attempt to solve a problem Einstein had encountered, Dr. Noether realized that all the most powerful and fundamental laws of physics, such as 鈥渆nergy can neither be created nor destroyed鈥 are in fact the consequence of a deep simplicity 鈥 symmetry 鈥 hiding behind the curtains of reality. Dr. Noether鈥檚 theorem would have a profound effect on the trajectory of physics.

In addition to the many direct consequences of Noether鈥檚 theorem is a longstanding tradition amongst physicists to treat symmetry thoughtfully. Because of its role in the fabric of our universe, carefully considering the symmetries of a system often leads to invaluable insights.

Einstein, Pauli and Noether walk into a bar...

Many of the systems we are interested in simulating with quantum computers are, at their heart, systems of electrons. Whether we are looking at how electrons move in a paired dance inside superconductors, or how they form orbitals and bonds in a chemical system, the motion of electrons are at the core.

Seven years after Noether published her blockbuster results, Wolfgang Pauli made waves when he published the work describing his Pauli exclusion principle, which relies heavily on symmetry to explain basic tenets of quantum theory. Pauli鈥檚 principle has enormous consequences; for starters, describing how the objects we interact with every day are solid even though atoms are mostly empty space, and outlining the rules of bonds, orbitals, and all of chemistry, among other things.

Symmetry in motion

It is Pauli's symmetry, coupled with a deep respect for the impact of symmetry, that led our team at 黑料社 to the discovery published today.

In their work, they considered the act of designing quantum algorithms, and how one鈥檚 design choices may lead to efficiency or inefficiency.

When you design quantum algorithms, there are many choices you can make that affect the final result. Extensive work goes into optimizing each individual step in an algorithm, requiring a cyclical process of determining subroutine improvements, and finally, bringing it all together. The significant cost and time required is a limiting factor in optimizing many algorithms of interest.

This is again where symmetry comes into play. The authors realized that by better exploiting the deepest symmetries of the problem, they could make the entire edifice more efficient, from state preparation to readout. Over the course of a few years, a team lead Dr. Fitzpatrick and his colleague J臋drzej Burkat slowly polished their approach into a full algorithm for performing the QPT.

The QPT functions by using Pauli鈥檚 symmetry to discard unimportant details and strip the problem down to its bare essentials. Starting with a Paldus transform allows the algorithm designer to enjoy knock-on effects throughout the entire structure, making it overall more efficient to run.

鈥淚t鈥檚 amazing to think how something we discovered one hundred years ago is making quantum computing easier and more efficient,鈥 said Dr. Nathan Fitzpatrick.

Ultimately, this innovation will lead to more efficient quantum simulation. Projects we believed to still be many years out can now be realized in the near term.

Transforming the future

The discovery of the Quantum Paldus Transform is a powerful reminder that enduring ideas鈥攍ike symmetry鈥攃ontinue to shape the frontiers of science. By reaching back into the fundamental principles laid down by pioneers like Noether and Pauli, and combining them with modern quantum algorithm design, Dr. Fitzpatrick and Mr. Burkat have uncovered a tool with the potential to reshape how we approach quantum computation.

As quantum technologies continue their crossover from theoretical promise to practical implementation, innovations like this will be key in unlocking their full potential.

technical
All
Blog
July 2, 2025
Cracking the code of superconductors: Quantum computers just got closer to the dream

, we've made a major breakthrough in one of quantum computing鈥檚 most elusive promises: simulating the physics of superconductors. A deeper understanding of superconductivity would have an enormous impact: greater insight could pave the way to real-world advances, like phone batteries that last for months, 鈥渓ossless鈥 power grids that drastically reduce your bills, or MRI machines that are widely available and cheap to use. 聽The development of room-temperature superconductors would transform the global economy.

A key promise of quantum computing is that it has a natural advantage when studying inherently quantum systems, like superconductors. In many ways, it is precisely the deeply 鈥榪uantum鈥 nature of superconductivity that makes it both so transformative and so notoriously difficult to study.

Now, we are pleased to report that we just got a lot closer to that ultimate dream.

Making the impossible possible

To study something like a superconductor with a quantum computer, you need to first 鈥渆ncode鈥 the elements of the system you want to study onto the qubits 鈥 in other words, you want to translate the essential features of your material onto the states and gates you will run on the computer.

For superconductors in particular, you want to encode the behavior of particles known as 鈥渇ermions鈥 (like the familiar electron). Naively simulating fermions using qubits will result in garbage data, because qubits alone lack the key properties that make a fermion so unique.

Until recently, scientists used something called the 鈥淛ordan-Wigner鈥 encoding to properly map fermions onto qubits. People have argued that the Jordan-Wigner encoding is one of the main reasons fermionic simulations have not progressed beyond simple one-dimensional chain geometries: it requires too many gates as the system size grows. 聽

Even worse, the Jordan-Wigner encoding has the nasty property that it is, in a sense, maximally non-fault-tolerant: one error occurring anywhere in the system affects the whole state, which generally leads to an exponential overhead in the number of shots required. Due to this, until now, simulating relevant systems at scale 鈥 one of the big promises of quantum computing 鈥 has remained a daunting challenge.

Theorists have addressed the issues of the Jordan-Wigner encoding and have suggested alternative fermionic encodings. In practice, however, the circuits created from these alternative encodings come with large overheads and have so far not been practically useful.

We are happy to report that our team developed a new way to compile one of the new, alternative, encodings that dramatically improves both efficiency and accuracy, overcoming the limitations of older approaches. Their new compilation scheme is the most efficient yet, slashing the cost of simulating fermionic hopping by an impressive 42%. On top of that, the team also introduced new, targeted error mitigation techniques that ensure even larger systems can be simulated with far fewer computational "shots"鈥攁 critical advantage in quantum computing.

Using their innovative methods, the team was able to simulate the Fermi-Hubbard model鈥攁 cornerstone of condensed matter physics鈥 at a previously unattainable scale. By encoding 36 fermionic modes into 48 physical qubits on System Model H2, they achieved the largest quantum simulation of this model to date.

This marks an important milestone in quantum computing: it demonstrates that large-scale simulations of complex quantum systems, like superconductors, are now within reach.

Unlocking the Quantum Age, One Breakthrough at a Time

This breakthrough doesn鈥檛 just show how we can push the boundaries of what quantum computers can do; it brings one of the most exciting use cases of quantum computing much closer to reality. With this new approach, scientists can soon begin to simulate materials and systems that were once thought too complex for the most powerful classical computers alone. And in doing so, they鈥檝e unlocked a path to potentially solving one of the most exciting and valuable problems in science and technology: understanding and harnessing the power of superconductivity.

The future of quantum computing鈥攁nd with it, the future of energy, electronics, and beyond鈥攋ust got a lot more exciting.

technical
All
Blog
July 1, 2025
黑料社 with partners Princeton and NIST deliver seminal result in quantum error correction

, we鈥檝e just delivered a crucial result in Quantum Error Correction (QEC), demonstrating key principles of scalable quantum computing developed by Drs Peter Shor, Dorit Aharonov, and Michael Ben-Or. we showed that by using 鈥渃oncatenated codes鈥 noise can be exponentially suppressed 鈥 proving that quantum computing will scale.

When noise is low enough, the results are transformative

Quantum computing is already producing results, but high-profile applications like Shor鈥檚 algorithm鈥攚hich can break RSA encryption鈥攔equire error rates about a billion times lower than what today鈥檚 machines can achieve.

Achieving such low error rates is a holy grail of quantum computing. Peter Shor was the first to hypothesize a way forward, in the form of quantum error correction. Building on his results, Dorit Aharanov and Michael Ben-Or proved that by concatenating quantum error correcting codes, a sufficiently high-quality quantum computer can suppress error rates arbitrarily at the cost of a very modest increase in the required number of qubits. 聽Without that insight, building a truly fault-tolerant quantum computer would be impossible.

Their results, now widely referred to as the 鈥渢hreshold theorem鈥, laid the foundation for realizing fault-tolerant quantum computing. At the time, many doubted that the error rates required for large-scale quantum algorithms could ever be achieved in practice. The threshold theorem made clear that large scale quantum computing is a realistic possibility, giving birth to the robust quantum industry that exists today.

Realizing a legendary vision

Until now, nobody has realized the original vision for the threshold theorem. Last year, in a different context (without concatenated codes). This year, we are proud to report the first experimental realization of that seminal work鈥攄emonstrating fault-tolerant quantum computing using concatenated codes, just as they envisioned.

The benefits of concatenation

The team demonstrated that their family of protocols achieves high error thresholds鈥攎aking them easier to implement鈥攚hile requiring minimal ancilla qubits, meaning lower overall qubit overhead. Remarkably, their protocols are so efficient that fault-tolerant preparation of basis states requires zero ancilla overhead, making the process maximally efficient.

This approach to error correction has the potential to significantly reduce qubit requirements across multiple areas, from state preparation to the broader QEC infrastructure. Additionally, concatenated codes offer greater design flexibility, which makes them especially attractive. Taken together, these advantages suggest that concatenation could provide a faster and more practical path to fault-tolerant quantum computing than popular approaches like the .

We鈥檙e always looking forward

From a broader perspective, this achievement highlights the power of collaboration between industry, academia, and national laboratories. 黑料社鈥檚 commercial quantum systems are so stable and reliable that our partners were able to carry out this groundbreaking research remotely鈥攐ver the cloud鈥攚ithout needing detailed knowledge of the hardware. While we very much look forward to welcoming them to our labs before long, its notable that they never need to step inside to harness the full capabilities of our machines.

As we make quantum computing more accessible, the rate of innovation will only increase. The era of plug-and-play quantum computing has arrived. Are you ready?

technical
All